Let’s start with an interesting case
Imagine you are the HR manager of Deloitte LLP, a leading auditing firm.
You are looking to hire an Audit Executive to perform the following responsibilities
Assist Audit Senior/Manager in carrying out the audit
Follow up with clients on audit & related issues
Job Requirements:
Diploma in Accountancy/Business Management/Finance
Possess good command of English
Meticulous in carrying out the assignments
Prior audit internship experience will be an added advantage
2 candidates applied for this position…
Now, let’s critique!
First Candidate: Darren Lee Zhi Xi
Language is perfect; there are no grammatical errors
Shows that he possesses a strong command of the English language
Includes relevant job experience
Provides substantial details about the nature of his role that is very similar to the responsibilities of the job he is applying to i.e. assist Audit Senior/Manager in carrying out the audit & follow up with clients on audit & related issues
Uses a high-resolution, professional-looking photograph
Uses a professional-sounding email address
A brief personal statement that shares about his skills and traits useful for the role
Second Candidate: Carrie Li Mei
Makes simple language errors
Does not possess a good command of the English language
Provides irrelevant job experience information such as working as a barista
Does not show her competencies
She assisted the Audit Senior/Manager in simple tasks instead of audit & related issues
Shows tactlessness and selfishness through her career objectives
Talks about self-enrichment instead of how she can contribute to the company and the role
Contradicts the traits required for the role
Talks about working fast so that she can go home early
She is most likely not a meticulous employee
A bad photograph
A comical email address
Inconsistent font sizes & capitalisation e.g. Job Experience compared to other headings
Shows that she is not meticulous again
Disclaimer: Names, characters, businesses, places, events and incidents are either the products of the author’s imagination or used in a fictitious manner. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental.
For enquiries about our quality English lessons or writing services, please contact The Useful English Tutor at 9747-0937.
Comments